Saturday, December 14, 2013

Summary of Tanzania Experience






David and I were asked to share our experiences with Cross-Cultural Solutions in Tanzania at our synagogue. The following are our remarks.


David and I recently had a wonderful opportunity to spend 5 weeks in Tanzania. It was a gift, really. We taught 12-14 year old students for 4 weeks, then went on a 4 day safari.

The safari was wonderful. We saw zebras, giraffes, wildebeest and other wild animals just yards away. We saw lions, several females and several cubs, resting in the road. The jeep that we traveled in had an open roof, so we could stand up and look out over the top to take photos with an unobstructed view. On more than one occasion we had to wait while elephants crossed the road. All of these amazing animals we saw close up in a stunning environment: the seemingly infinite plains of the Serengeti. But, the experience of seeing the animals and the Serengeti ecosystem, paled in comparison to our teaching experience with the Tanzanian youth.

Let me take you to the school. Let’s walk together.  It’s about a 1 ½ mile walk. We leave the volunteer residence, then turn left onto a narrow, unfinished road. A dirt road. Uneven. Rutted. Worst of all: dusty. When trucks or motorcycles drive by, they raise huge clouds of dust.  We very quickly hated the dust. But, as we walked along, we were greeted by very friendly locals, by children going to school, by people doing chores outside their homes, and by vendors in their tiny road side shops. These were our new neighbors. They greeted us warmly in Swahili and we knew enough Swahili to respond.

The area where we lived and worked was in the northeast part of the country. It’s a fairly rural area. Many residents of the area are farmers. As we walked down this dusty, dirt road we passed banana trees, mango trees and fields of other crops. We passed small houses made of mud or adobe bricks with sheets of corrugated metal for a roof.
The area is known as the Kilimanjaro region, because it lies in the foothills of Mt. Kilimanjaro, which is the highest point in Africa. We had wonderful views of Mt. Kilimanjaro’s magnificent snow-capped peak every day as we walked down this road. 

We loved this daily walk. 

After a mile and a half of walking, we arrive at Best Hope School. The six foot high wall surrounding the grounds is raw brick and mortar. The gate, rough wood and rickety. The courtyard is bare, trampled dirt with one tree that graciously offered shade. The school has no electricity. No running water. No plumbing.

To our right in the courtyard is the teachers’ small office. It has a cement floor and walls. But, next to that is our classroom. A room about 10 by 20 feet with raw brick walls - Not enough money right now to finish the walls. A dirt floor, and a tin roof. Two large openings in one wall serve as windows. Just wide open spaces in the wall. No glass or other window covering.

The tin roof doesn’t fit tightly against the walls – it isn’t rain-proof. So when it rains, rain enters the classroom through the window openings and through open spaces between the roof and the walls – and the dirt floor becomes a pit of mud.

There is a rickety blackboard leaning against one wall. One box of chalk is shared by the three teachers and their classrooms. A rag is used as an eraser. The benches are crude wood, and the desks are unsteady metal folding tables. The students in our class sit shoulder to shoulder, 3 or 4 sharing a short bench and a narrow table.

There are no posters on the walls. There is very little wall space and the walls aren’t smooth enough to hang anything. 

In theory, Tanzanian law requires that all children attend Primary School and Primary School is said to be “free”. Many children, however, live in extremely rural and impoverished areas, where the hope of attending school is a distant dream. 

Many poor parents can’t afford the required uniforms, school materials and examination fees, so their children are unable to complete even Primary School. Other children are unable to attend because the nearest school is too far away or because they need to work in the fields or help with chores at home. Many children who do attend school go on an empty stomach. For every two children who start school in Tanzania, one drops outs before finishing primary education. 

At the end of Primary School, every student in the country is required to take a national exam, which determines the student’s educational future. Only 50% of students pass the national qualifying exam and continue to Secondary School.

Our students had all taken the national exam and were waiting for their scores, which would determine if they could enroll in a government-run Secondary School. The program they were enrolled in at Best Hope School was to help prepare them for Secondary School, in the hope that their examination scores would be high enough for them to begin Secondary School in January.
One of the hurdles Tanzanian students face as they transition from Primary School into Secondary School is an abrupt shift from instruction in Swahili to instruction in English. As Swahili is the official language in Tanzania, it is the language of instruction in Primary Schools. All Primary School textbooks, except for a class in English, are written in Swahili.
English, however, is the language of instruction in Secondary School. All textbooks used in Secondary Schools are in English. This abrupt language shift often results in a high performing student spiraling into a very low performing student, and sometimes dropping out of school entirely. Most students have little opportunity to practice English effectively to ensure their academic success in an all-English Secondary School classroom.
What type of educational resources does Best Hope School have?

The curriculum is ambitious. The school day lasts from 8:00 A.M. to 12:30 P.M., which includes four 1-hour long class periods and a 30 minute break; and the schedule calls for instruction in Math, Biology, History, Geology, Civics and English.

For each subject, there is one book for the entire class. It’s the textbook that the teacher holds as he teaches. The students have no textbooks of their own.

Our class had about 17 students. During each class, the teacher copies sections of the book word for word onto the blackboard and the students copy from the blackboard into their paper notebooks. They will be expected to memorize the material and recite it verbatim. Word for word. They learn almost everything by rote.

School supplies: Each student has a ballpoint pen. About ¼ to 1/3 of the class has pencils. Two students have erasers. And a different two have rulers. They share supplies.

As will be the case in Secondary School, the big challenge for students at Best Hope School is that the text-book is in English and the language of instruction is in English. The students, however, grew up speaking and learning in Swahili. Their knowledge of English is extremely limited at best.

Their teachers’ command of English is also limited. When the teachers lead the classes, it is not clear to us how much of the material they actually understand themselves.    
                                              
What was our role as volunteer teachers? 

Initially, as we were becoming familiar with the classroom routine, we assisted the teachers by explaining material to the students that was difficult for them to understand. Very soon, however, we started conducting classes in their entirety, as the regular teachers were frequently absent or they were busy attending to matters outside the classroom. When we took over a class, we concentrated on English and Math, which were the easiest subjects for us to teach.

By the start of our last week as volunteer teachers, the regular teachers acknowledged that English was the most important subject for the students to be studying at that time and that we were more capable of teaching English than they were. So they deferred to us to do all the teaching during our last week and we focused on English, with some Math lessons to break it up.

These students were so eager to learn. They were very attentive. They diligently took notes and completed all of the exercises that we gave them.

During breaks between classes, we enjoyed hanging out with them. I taught them how to play dominoes. We played word games with little plastic letter tiles, and I taught them some English songs. David was very popular because the 4-6 year olds in the other classes loved to be tossed and spun around.  They were great kids. We so enjoyed our four weeks with them.  We miss them.

Why did we go to Tanzania?

We started with the goal of living in a new place and experiencing a different culture for an extended period of time.

However, we have a long history of volunteering, starting with our service together as Peace Corps Volunteers right after we were married. Over the years we have enjoyed doing volunteer work with the Madison Literacy Network, with Madison’s Jewish Congregations for Social Justice group, which sponsors a partnership with Emerson School, and with the Beth Israel Center’s personnel committee, to name just a few.

It was natural for us, therefore, to decide to volunteer abroad:  to merge our interests in experiencing a new culture and working on social issues or a worthwhile cause.

What did we accomplish?

I’d like to think that we influenced a few students and taught them a few things. That we enhanced their English language skills.

We also hope that we modeled different teaching techniques for the teachers. We felt we had to work within the school’s traditional practices, but we tweaked the rules to be somewhat more creative. We tried to demonstrate that learning is not simply copying information and reciting it back word for word.

We tried to be learning ambassadors from America. Showing the students that education is important and that we cared about them. That we cared about their success.

Yes, we had some achievements, but, we received so much more. We developed relationships with wonderful people. Tanzanians who welcomed us sincerely and with open hearts. 

I miss the students. Junior, who wore the same red t-shirt and blue pants every day for four weeks. He wants to be a pilot. I miss Glory. Her English wasn’t strong, but she was whip-smart. All the girls and boys wore their hair very short. When we called on Glory in class, she would rub her head in anxiety, she would look down in her shy manner, but, usually came up with the right answer. One day she was so excited to show me her score on the math exam. 98%.

We also enjoyed the natural beauty of this lush region in Tanzania. Each day as we walked back from school to the volunteer residence, we passed an open field. Looking over the field we saw a magnificent view of Mt Kilimanjaro: the highest mountain in Africa, and the highest free-standing mountain in the world at 19,341 feet above sea level.

The organization that we went with was Cross-Cultural Solutions. CCS has volunteer programs in 12 countries around the globe. They found a perfect placement for us and provided an orientation that prepared us well. We learned some Swahili and a lot about local culture. The in-country support made us feel safe and enabled us to focus on the students, our volunteer work.

Do I believe international volunteerism is worthwhile? Absolutely.
You may start with a desire to travel, learn a new language, or meet new people. To live in a new place for an extended period of time. But immersing yourself more deeply in the local culture, and providing support to communities through hands-on service:


  •  Helps you understand the world better and the forces that keep people impoverished;

  •    Enhances your appreciation for the richness of other cultures; and


  •  Volunteering gave me a  new perspective on my own cultural values and assumptions.


Was this a life changing event?

Definitely. In the short term, I think every day about the people I met. The students: Junior, Glory, Stephen, Happiness, Inocent! Inocent turned out to be not so innocent!

The woman in the out-door market who helped me wrap the local fabric I had bought (a Kaanga) around my waist correctly. Then all her friends, the other vendors nearby, applauded.

The secondary students we met at a park, who greeted us warmly and were very curious about my hair. With no inhibitions, they just reached up and touched it.  As we parted, they said to us: “Welcome to Tanzania. We hope you are comfortable here.”

But, what will I do differently now that I’m back in Madison. I will volunteer more.  I’ve started to do research on the issue of hunger, or food insecurity, in Dane County and hope to work on that issue.

I’ll continue to work within the area of education through our partnership with Emerson School. Volunteering. Recruiting volunteers. Building relationships with new people.

In conclusion:

Was volunteering in Tanzania an amazing experience? Yes.

Would I do it again? Yes. In a minute.

Do I recommend that you volunteer? Yes. Because you can work on some important local or global issues.  But, more so, because it will enrich your life.

Thank you for listening to our story.